Old West icon Wyatt Earp’s Tombstone is, of course, legendary—but his actual tombstone has a lot of stories to tell, too.

Most Wild West fans will be surprised to learn that Earp is buried not in Tombstone, Arizona, nor Dodge City. Instead, his final resting place is at the Hills of Eternity Jewish cemetery in Colma, California. No, he wasn’t Jewish—but his last wife was.

Wikimedia Commons // Public Domain

Upon his death in 1929—not because of a shootout, but due to complications from a urinary tract infection—his wife, Josephine, had him cremated and buried in her family plot, which she was a bit secretive about. When she died in 1944, very few people knew of Wyatt's whereabouts. But someone must have known, because the original tombstone was stolen shortly after she died.

In 1957, the Tombstone Restoration Committee expressed interest in having the legend's ashes moved to Tombstone, Arizona, to attract tourists—but no one seemed to know what had become of them. After many inquiries, Arthur King, one of Earp’s deputies, revealed the location of his former boss's urn: the Hills of Eternity Jewish cemetery in Colma.

Stacy Conradt

The Tombstone Restoration Committee gave up their bid to move Earp—but shortly thereafter, his 300-pound granite marker was stolen, marking the second time the grave had been desecrated. The thieves had been after more than just the stone: They dug a hole 5 feet deep, apparently searching for the urn containing the sheriff's ashes. Thankfully, their efforts were unsuccessful. Though the timing was slightly suspicious, the city of Tombstone was quick to deny any involvement. “We think it was a pretty low trick for anyone to steal that marker in California,” the secretary of the Tombstone Chamber of Commerce commented. “And don’t get the idea we stole the stone.”

Actor Hugh O’Brian, who played the title role in the TV show The Life and Legend of Wyatt Earp, offered a reward for its safe return, but no one claimed it. The stone was reportedly found several months later in a clump of bushes on a roadside in San Bruno, California—only to disappear again, possibly removed by cemetery officials to prevent further theft. The current marker, much larger and presumably harder to steal than the first two, was placed in the late 1990s. Whatever the cemetery is doing to prevent it from being stolen seems to be working—or maybe people have just decided that stealing from a legendary lawman is a pretty bad idea.

Peruse all the entries in our Grave Sightings series here.